Caffeine.supply

Top 10 Highest Rated Specialty Coffees

Top 10 coffees · 2026 · Ranked by expert rating

These are the top-rated coffees in our entire database of 623 specialty beans, ranked by expert score. Each earned its spot through exceptional cup quality, distinctive provenance, and outstanding roaster craft.

#1
Colombia Pink Bourbon by Heart Coffee Roasters
Heart Coffee Roasters
Colombia Pink Bourbon
Colombia · $25.00
★ 4.9WashedLight Roast
#2
Finca Deborah Nirvana Geisha by Corvus Coffee Roasters
Corvus Coffee Roasters
Finca Deborah Nirvana Geisha
Panama · $65.00
★ 4.9Nitrogen Anaerobic NaturalLight Roast
#3
Decaf Mexico by Temple Coffee Roasters
Temple Coffee Roasters
Decaf Mexico
Mexico · $18.00
★ 4.8Swiss Water Process DecafMedium Roast
#4
Ethiopia Rumadamo Anaerobic Natural by Olympia Coffee Roasting
Olympia Coffee Roasting
Ethiopia Rumadamo Anaerobic Natural
Ethiopia · $19.00
★ 4.8Anaerobic NaturalLight Roast
#5
Colombia El Diviso by Ruby Coffee Roasters
Ruby Coffee Roasters
Colombia El Diviso
Colombia · $19.45
★ 4.8Washed AnaerobicLight Roast
#6
Mexico Finca Chelin Hydronatural by Intelligentsia Coffee
Intelligentsia Coffee
Mexico Finca Chelin Hydronatural
Mexico · $20.00
★ 4.8HydronaturalLight Roast
#7
Synthesis by Ceremony Coffee Roasters
Ceremony Coffee Roasters
Synthesis
Colombia · $21.00
★ 4.8WashedMedium-Dark Roast
#8
Rwanda Muhororo Ireme Anaerobic Natural by Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx Coffee Lab
Rwanda Muhororo Ireme Anaerobic Natural
Rwanda · $21.50
★ 4.8Anaerobic NaturalLight Roast
#9
Tropical Weather by Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx Coffee Lab
Tropical Weather
Ethiopia · $21.50
★ 4.8Washed / NaturalLight Roast
#10
Guatemala Finca Isnul by Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx Coffee Lab
Guatemala Finca Isnul
Guatemala · $22.00
★ 4.8WashedLight Roast